Most Haunted TV Show finally catches an apparition!

Yvette Fielding and Dr Karl Beattie fron TV Show Most HauntedAs a skeptical paranormal researcher and investigator,  I find most ghost shows a little bit hard to take seriously.   Most Haunted in its history has had some supposedly “fake” Physics.

Derek Acorah was supposedly outed in a live show by a false ghost made up by the team called Kreed Kafer,  an anagram of Derek Faker.

Most Haunted and Yvette and Karl really have stood firm on how they want the show to be real and nothing faked and so as a Paranormal TV show,  Most Haunted has stood the test of time and is well into double figures for its series.

Allot of this is due to the on-screen chemistry of the team.  Karl and Yvette (of Blue Peter fame) pictured here to the right are the lead 2 investigators.  They are also husband and wife.

This footage that has exploded onto the paranormal community is the most compelling, “alleged”, Ghostly Apparitions we have ever seen.

The “alleged” apparition clearly walks up the stairs and has arms and legs and its pretty cool evidence.

However, yes,  I can’t help it.   The skeptic in me does question the actions of Stuart who runs after the apparition and looks past an open door before directing Karl into an empty room.

I love the show, the cast, and Stuart,   I am not making an accusation but the skeptic in me immediately questioned what Stuart looked at past the open door before directing Karl into the side room.

Was he making sure the person playing a part got out okay?

I’m writing this without seeing the entire show as I have only yet seen the clips online so I might not have the full information on the layout of the corridor,  he could of been checking inf the apparition had passed through the door and onward and perhaps they continued on after what we see in the clip.

Also, the outline and the gait of the apparition makes me question it.  It more resembles a crew member wearing baggy jeans and a hoody,  darker clothes which on night vision would show up lighter.  It just doesn’t feel like a long-dead ghost of long past.  Granted it could be someone recently deceased,  its just a strange apparition outline.

Again,  we love Most Haunted and so want it to be real but I just have that skeptical voice in my head just getting at me so I have to put it out there.

Also the show does carry a declaration that its for entertainment purposes only so it makes it harder to take this as real evidence.

It will definitely raise interest in the field and help the shows ratings,  neither of which are a bad thing but we at V.I.P.S. really really want it to be real too.

Robert Turner
Vancouver Island Paranormal Soc.



Likely faked,  this like an alleged Queen Mary Apparition were both when camera’s had been set down on a surface,  this is because its hard to do video overlay with a shaky camera.  Queen Mary footage is widely seen as a hoax now.

Lake Monsters Or Lily Pads

cammie sighting at Cameron Lake

‘Cammie’ sighting at Cameron Lake

“Cammie” Lake monster sightings are on the rise as Cameron Lake on Vancouver Island and it started a discussion about the whole lake monster phenomenon.

We here at V.I.P.S. are forming a hypothesis that might explain some sightings.  The wake that is seen as they surface and dive, the bumps that are seen in a row.

Type of root systems that can be rotting in lake beds

Type of root systems that can be rotting in lake beds

Rotting Stumps and/or underwater root systems like lily pads which can become very large and undulating.  See in the image a possible root system.  It appears to have scales like that of a lizard or serpent.  and it branches off,  imagine that rolling on the surface of the water and a part rising out of the water as it does so. What could be a pretty compelling monster sighting.

As the fleshy root rots. It causes gas build up in the root itself that would cause it to rise to the surface.  Gas escaping from the root propels it across the surface. Due to its undulating nature it forms the humps that are synonymous with a lake monster sighting.  Another theory of the propulsion could be fish, a large fish would swim into the root as it tried to bite parts off it,  this could also account for direction changes, splashing and rolling. You can see that happen when you throw bread in a lake with Carp.  They swim at the bread as they try to bite pieces off propelling it across the water.

As gas escapes water enters the spaces and the root sinks.   Movement in a monster sighting could be high pressure gas release causing the same effect you would get with a high pressure hose or a rolling effect of the root system possible causing protrusions from the lake surface,  a head coming up our of the water and then going under again.

V.I.P.S would love ‘Cammie’ to be real and we not discounting it.  We do like to promote ‘open mindedness’ and so are a putting it out there an an alternative idea for discussion,  something to keep in mind when watching a youtube video sighting.  We are interested in your lake monster encounters and thoughts on this topic, keep it constructive.

If you are into the Lake Monster phenomenon check out:

Memphre: the lake monster update – JOHN MAHONEY
On the Vermont/Quebec frontier


Great Books on Lake Monsters:

The Field Guide to Lake Monsters, Sea Serpents, and Other Mystery Denizens of the Deep

The Field Guide to Lake Monsters, Sea Serpents, and Other Mystery Denizens of the Deep

Lake Monster Mysteries: Investigating the World’s Most Elusive Creatures

Lake Monster Mysteries: Investigating the World's Most Elusive Creatures

Doris Gravlin

A little further digging turned up a 2008 story by Dave Obee in the TV about the haunting and a cartoon from personal friend Adrian Raeside :

Ghost of slain woman said to haunt Victoria Golf Club

Dozens of sightings have been reported

She is still with us, they say, stopping traffic with her haunting stares. Doris Charnock Thomson Gravlin was just 30 years old when she suddenly disappeared in September 1936, along with her estranged husband Victor. A few days later her body was found. She had been killed, suffocated to death on a golf course.

But, if you believe in ghosts, Doris has been seen many times since then, on or about the Victoria Golf Club links where she died.

Victor’s body was found in the water next to the golf course almost a month after his wife’s body was discovered. Unlike his wife, he is really gone.

It is only fitting to note, as we celebrate the 150th anniversary of the British Colonist, that our newspaper was part of the story. Victor Raymond Gravlin had worked as the sport editor at the Daily Colonist for about 10 years. He left the newspaper in 1934, two years before he and his wife died.

Doris Gravlin was born Doris Charnock on Sept. 13, 1906, in Manor House, Blackburn, Lancashire, England. Her parents were Walter Charnock and his wife Charlotte.

When Doris was just nine years old, in the spring of 1916, Walter Gravlin died. Charlotte had a married sister living in Victoria, so on Dec. 9, she and Doris boarded the Northland in Liverpool, heading for Halifax. They arrived there on Dec. 18, 1916, then set out for Victoria by train.

How long they stayed in Victoria is not known. By April 1918 they were living in Vancouver. On April 12, Charlotte Charnock married a motor mechanic, Robert Thomson, at the home they shared on Arbutus Street in Vancouver.

Soon after that they moved to Victoria, and Charlotte resumed her career as a nurse.

Doris was working as a sales clerk when she met Victor Gravlin, the man who would become her husband. They were married in Victoria’s Temple Hall on March 8, 1929.

Victor had been born in Victoria on Oct. 23, 1899, the son of Herbert Thomas Gravlin, who worked as a paper hanger — interior decorator, basically — and the former Elizabeth Kenny.

He had two sisters and three brothers.

Victor was active in sports, which led to work as a sports writer.

At first, everything seemed to be going well for Victor and Doris, and their son Walter was born in Victoria on Dec. 23, 1930.

In 1934, however, Victor “was taken ill,” accordingly to the newspapers of the day. He spent several months in hospital and never regained the robust health that he had previously enjoyed.

At about the same time, Doris and little Walter moved in with her mother and stepfather, Charlotte and Robert Thomson.

Doris started working as a private nurse.

When he got out of hospital, Victor went to live with his parents on Oak Bay Avenue.

On the evening of Tuesday, Sept. 22, 1936, Doris left her place of employment, an apartment on Beach Drive in Oak Bay.

About the same time, Victor left the home of his parents.

The following Sunday, photographs of both Doris and Victor appeared in the Colonist under the headline “Missing since Tuesday.”

“Victor Gravlin and his wife, Doris Gravlin, missing from their respective homes since last Tuesday, are being sought throughout Greater Victoria,” the newspaper said.

The Colonist described Victor as weighing about 135 pounds with medium build. He had a nervous temperament, the paper said. Doris was described as having auburn hair and large brown eyes, and was wearing a knitted dress, blue coat with silver buttons, and a grey hat.

Late in the afternoon that day, golf caddy John Johnson, who had been searching for a lost ball, found the body of Doris. It had been covered with brush in a secluded area of the course.

Police said they were still looking for Victor. There had been reports, they said, that Doris and Victor had been seen together on Foul Bay Road near Runnymede Avenue at about 8:45 p.m. Tuesday, walking southward. There were also reports that a scream had been heard at about 9 on Tuesday, with the sound coming from the golf course.

Doris was missing her shoes, her hat and her coat. Police scoured the golf course looking for evidence, enlisting a corps of Boy Scouts to help. They tried bloodhounds as well, but the passage of time had left much of the trail cold.

A coroner’s jury was assembled, with members James Macrimmon, Edwin Brown, George Burnell, James Adamson, Edward Wilkinson and Michael Heppell. The jury determined that Doris had been strangled to death by “person or persons unknown.”

Apparently Doris had been beaten before being strangled. Some bruises on her body had apparently been caused when her body was dragged to its hiding spot.

Oak Bay police issued a warrant for Victor, naming him as a suspect in his wife’s death. That meant, the Colonist said, that police probably believed Victor was still alive. The newspaper also suggested that Victor might have left the city disguised as a woman. That would have helped explain the Doris’s missing hat and coat.

Police distributed several hundred circulars noting that Victor Gravlin was wanted for murder, but in the days that followed, they had no luck finding him.

On Sunday, Oct. 26, four weeks to the day after the discovery of Doris’s body, a local man using a boat to look for golf balls found Victor’s body in the water next to the golf course.

Norman Le Poidevan contacted police, who used the man’s boat to bring the body ashore.

Victor’s body was fully clothed. In his coat pockets, police found Doris’s shoes. That closed the case. Walter, the son of Victor and Doris, stayed with Doris’s mother Charlotte and her husband Robert Thomson. The Thomsons ran a sanitarium on Montrose Avenue, then a health centre on Glanford Road in the Royal Oak district.

Little Walter Gravlin took the name Robin Charnock Thomson. In 1949 he went to Sandhurst Military College in England, and never returned to Canada. Before he died in October 1994, he was in charge of public transport in the Midlands.

On Oct. 1, 1936, Doris’s body was shipped to Seattle for cremation, something not yet possible on Vancouver Island. Ten years later her ashes were interred in an area of Royal Oak Burial Park reserved for cremated remains.

She is at rest there, in theory at least. In the years since her passing there have been dozens of sightings of a ghost next to the golf course. It’s believed the ghost is Doris, although another thought is that it might be Elizabeth Gravlin, still upset that her son Victor was blamed for the death of Doris.

One of these days, maybe someone will ask her for ID.

2 Vancouver Island Spots in the Top 10 Most Haunted Locations in Canada as featured in the Readers Digest

Spooks, spectres and spirits abound: Canada is rich with ghost stories and tales of the supernatural.  Vancouver Island can claim 2 locations in the Top 10 Most Haunted locations in Canada which are:

6. Craigdarroch Castle, Victoria, B.C.

Craigdarroch Castle, Victoria, B.C.Built in the 1890s for coal miner Robert Dunsmuir and his family, this Victorian-era mansion has since become an eerie Canadian tourist attraction. Rumors of a piano that plays by itself, and sightings of a ghostly woman in white have frequently been reported. Many attribute the castle’s supernatural proclivity to Dunsmuir’s untimely demise just a year before the building was completed.

(Photo courtesy of It_paris/Flickr)


8. Maritime Museum of B.C., Victoria, B.C.

Maritime Museum of B.C., Victoria, B.C.

(Photo courtesy of **Mary**/Flickr)

The dearly departed seem to have a fondness for the city cheekily known as the place for the “newly-wed and nearly-dead”. Located in Victoria’s well-known Bastion Square is the Maritime Museum, which was once the site of the city’s jail and gallows. Some say that if you look through the windows at the Museum’s entrance, a shadowy, slender, Van Dyke-bearded figure can be spotted gliding down the main staircase. The mysterious apparition is thought to be the ghost of Sir Matthew Baillie Begbie, Victoria’s infamous “Hanging Judge”.


Find out the No 1 spot and the 0ther 7 at

Boo to for not getting any Vancouver Island Spots in its top 8!. gets one in its Top 9 with Craigdarroch Castle and The Weather Network also fails to include Vancouver Island.  Suprising to us is Huffington Post who we thought had good articles who fail to include any locations on the island but do include some that we had not hear of in this older 2013 article.

Applause to BuzzFeed who feature 4 places in its top 14!